Halloween Costume Stores in New York City:

Frankie Stein
24 Harrison St. and 580 Broadway NY, NY
212-925-1373
www.frankiesteinz.com
By appointment only...High end…Makes costumes for celebrities, commercials, photo shoots, movies, etc…Every customer review on CitySearch.com gave her 5 stars

Abracadabra Superstore
”The Halloween Professionals”
19 W. 21st St. btwn 5th & 6th Aves.
(212) 627-5194
Claim to have over 100,000 items in stock- props, costumes, magic, juggling, gag  & novelties, etc… Everything from children’s costumes to erotic costumes & liquid latex J
Costumes are available for rental and purchase

Party City
38 W. 14th St.
(212) 271-7310
www.partycity.com
"Discount Party Superstore"
Most costumes are only in stock around Halloween
Large selection of costumes at a reasonable price, but the quality is not always great.
My advice is to try the costume on while you are at the store because they don't offer refunds, returns or exchanges and sometimes the costumes don't look as good on as they did on the package, and go early because they do sell out fast, although they do have a large selection of costumes.

New York Costumes
Halloween Adventure Fantasy Superstore
104 4th Ave.
www.newyorkcostumes.com
1-800-99-JUMPY
Open Year Round
"FAO Schwartz of Halloween Stores"
Customer reviews say that it's a really fun store & there's a huge selection of costumes, but the downside is they don't give refunds and you can't try anything on.

Screaming Mimis
382 Lafayette St
New York, NY 10003
Phone: (212) 677-6464
www.screamingmimis.com
Vintage Clothing store that begins to sell vintage Halloween costumes in October.

Manhattan Costumes
250 W 57th St Suite 1609
New York, NY 10107-1599
Phone: (212) 245-6770 (well liked, celebrity sightings)

Early Halloween
130 W 25th St Fl 11
New York, NY 10001-7406
Phone: (212) 691-2933

Spirit Halloween Superstore
East Village location: 384-388 Lafayette Street at West 4th Street, 212-253-2076
Upper West Side location: 2320 Broadway at 84th Street, 212-362-2031
www.spirithalloween.com

Rubie's Costume Company
120-08 Jamaica Avenue, Queens
718-846-1008
Low prices and a large selection
www.rubies.com

A la Disposition
330 W. 38th St
212-564-9029
www.aladisposition.com

All Action Wigs
318 W. 39th St. Fl. 10
212-695-0198

Arel Studios
242 W. 36th St.
212-268-5682

California Costume
1115 Broadway
(212) 620-7644

Carelli Costumes
109 W. 26th St.
(212) 765-6166

Cesar Incorporated
200 5th Ave.
(212) 228-6275

Cheap Jack's
841 Broadway
(212) 995-0403

Circa Now
238 E. 6th St.
212) 254-2555

Coe Sidney Company
306 W. 38th Rm 1505
(212) 631-0220

Costume National
108 Wooster at Spring St.
(212) 431-1530

Disguise Incorporated
1115 Broadway (W. 25th St.)
(212) 727-3267

Dodger Costume Rental
601 W. 26th
(212) 433-1111

Duffy & Quinn Incorporated
307 5th Avenue rm 1509
247 W. 37th
(212) 725-0213

Earl Douglas
225 W. 36th
(212) 564-5615

Euroco Costumes Incorporated
247 W. 30th
(212) 564-5615

Exquisite Costume LLC
337 Broome St.
(212) 966-4142

Gale Gregory Costume Design
315 W. 39th St. rm 610
(212) 736-2028

Grace Costumes Incorporated
250 W. 54th St.
(212) 586-0260

In Costume
10 Hillside Ave.
555 8th Ave. (38th St.)
(212) 290-2935

Jennifer Love Costumes
216 W. 18th St.
(212) 367-9114

Langman Donna Costumes
39 W. 38th St.
(212) 382-2558

Late Bloomers
205 W. 37th
(212) 730-8855

Lynne MacKey Studios
216 W. 35th
(212) 352-0668

Sweet Tater Incorporated
280 Mulberry St.
(212) 219-6400

The Costume Collection
601 W. 26th St.
(212) 989-5855

The Costume Depot
163 W. 23rd St. Fl 2
(212) 929-6733

The Costume Lab
601 W. 27th St.
(212) 352-8580

Zachary's Smile
9 Greenwich Ave.
(212) 924-0604